Categories
Articles

The Impacts of the Mercosur and European Union Agreement on Telecommunications in Brazil

Ericson Scorsim. Lawyer and Consultant in Communication Law, with a focus on Technologies, Media, and Telecommunications. PhD in Law from the University of São Paulo (USP).

Mercosur and the European Union entered into a proposed trade agreement with impact on various economic activities. The aim is to promote trade freedom of services and business establishments. But the agreement still must be approved internally by the legislature of each of the participating countries. In any case, it is an important step in bringing the countries of South America, which are part of Mercosur, closer to Europe. Regarding the telecommunications industry, there are several provisions that authorize service providers from any of the countries that have signed the agreement to establish, build, acquire, assign, operate or provide telecommunications networks or services. Broadcasting services, as well as services providing editorial content are excluded from the commercial agreement.

According to the agreement, the telecommunications regulatory authorities must publish their regulatory acts in a clear manner, to simplify their understanding. In addition, regulatory procedures must be impartial, with respect to all market participants. Licenses to provide telecommunications services should be granted, where possible, following a simplified procedure. The reasons for denying a license to provide telecommunications services must be known. Countries should adopt practices to protect competition and repress abuses by the dominant power. Also, the parties must ensure that the major telecommunications providers guarantee the right of access to other competitors in a reasonable and non-discriminatory manner. Any telecommunications service provider has the right to negotiate interconnection with other providers. For scarce resources such as radio spectrum, public allocation policies should be objective, timely, transparent, and non-discriminatory.

The frequency allocation plan must be publicly available. Each country has the right to define what the universal services are. On the other hand, the Parties must ensure the confidentiality of telecommunications and data traffic on public telecommunications networks to avoid arbitrary or unjustifiable discrimination in the trade of such services. Furthermore, the parties must ensure transparency and reasonable prices for international roaming services, to promote trade growth between countries and consumer welfare. The agreement also provides for freedom of trade.

However, it establishes some technical barriers to trade. Thus, Annex I contains safety rules regarding electronic and electrical equipment. Also, on the electromagnetic compatibility of equipment using radiocommunication. In addition, there are standards on energy efficiency certificates of products. And the restriction of toxic substances in electronic and electrical equipment. Moreover, it holds procedures for the declaration of technical conformity of the supplier of products, based on their responsibility before a certification body. And, still, there is the possibility of international mutual recognition through a validation system. In this regard, a Mercosur country may request technical recognition based on its legislation and regulations in bilateral agreements, including memorandum of understanding. In being recognized as valid the declaration of technical conformity, according to European Union’s procedure, the report of the test carried out by the advisory bodies located in the Mercosur countries, the document is valid before the European Union and its technical regulations.  In addition to these subjects, the agreement provides for rules on e-commerce. For the time being, the agreement between Mercosur and the European Union is still under negotiation.

The parliaments of the respective countries integrating the two regional blocs must adopt the procedures for approval of the aforementioned international treaty and incorporate it into their internal law. It should be noted that the European Union and the United States, in 1999, already signed an agreement on mutual recognition of telecommunications equipment and electromagnetic compatibility of products.[1] Also, the United States and the United Kingdom signed an agreement for mutual recognition of telecommunications equipment in 2011.[2] In short, this agreement between Mercosur and the European Union is an important step towards the international trade of telecommunications products and services, as well as the affirmation of international law related to the mutual recognition of declarations of technical conformity for telecommunications equipment, harmonizing international rules that impact telecommunications services.  Even more so now in the context of 5G technology and IoT devices, this international regulatory standardization is essential.  As mentioned, the integration of the international agreement depends on ratification by the parliaments of the countries that make up the two regional blocs, something that will take a few years.

[1] Agreement on mutual recognition between the European Community and the United States of America, which encompasses: Telecommunication equipment, electromagnetic compatibility (EMC), electrical safety, recreational craft, pharmaceutical good manufacturing practices e medical devices.

[2]See: Agreement on mutual recognition between The United States of America and The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, covering: telecommunications equipment, electromagnetic compatibility (EMC0) and pharmaceutical good manufacturing practices (GMPS0.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Temas de Direito da Comunicação na Jurisprudência do Supremo Tribunal Federal

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2017

Portuguese

Sold by: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

The Brazil Constitution celebrates the 30 (Thirtieth) anniversary in 2018.
The book Communication Law in the Case Law of the Brazilian Supreme Court, by the author Ericson M. Scorsim (PhD in Law, by Universidade de São Paulo), lawyer and consultant in Public Law, aims at honoring this historic and symbolic event in Brazil.
The book provides a comprehensive overview of Brazilian decisions on cases about the Regulatory Framework of the Internet, Telecommunications (Telecommunications Act), Broadcasting, Pay-TV (Pay-TV Act) and the Press, in the last three decades, from 1988 (when the Constitution of Brazil was approved) until 2018.
During this period of time, the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court established the basis of Communication Law.

Categories
Articles

U.S. Government’s Strategy to Contain China Involves Banning the Apps TikTok and WeChat

Ericson Scorsim. Lawyer and Consultant in Communication Law, focusing on Technologies, Internet, Media and Telecommunications.  PhD in Law from the University of São Paulo (USP). Author of the Communications Law Collection.

The US government has announced that it will ban the apps TikTok and WeChat. According to the government, applications originating from Chinese companies pose risks to U.S. national security, as they allow for the collection of sensitive data from U.S citizens and businesses.  According to the Executive Order issued by President Donald Trump under the International Emergency Economic Power Act and National Emergencies Act, and Executive Order 13.873 (securing the information and communications technology and services supply chain), WeChat, an application provided by Chinese company WeChat, captures immense amounts of U.S. data, which poses a national security risk.[1] In turn, the Executive Order on TikTok, a mobile application provided by the Chinese company Bytedance, adopts the same reasoning, and mentions that the video sharing application also collects huge amounts of data, including geolocation data and internet browsing history, representing a threat to the national security of the United States.[2] 

There is a risk that these apps are collecting personal data and tracking the location of federal government employees and contractors to obtain personal information for purposes of blackmail, extortion and/or corporate espionage. This national security policy is aligned with the following U.S. State Department strategies: i) Clean Carrier – the assurance of disconnection of Chinese telecommunications companies from the U.S. telecommunications networks; ii) Clean Store – the removal of untrustworthy applications of Chinese origin from U.S. company application stores given privacy risks, content censorship, and dissemination of advertising and misinformation; iii) Clean Apps – preventing Chinese mobile phone manufacturers from installing or making applications available in their application store, so U.S. companies must remove applications from the Huawei application store; iv) Clean Cloud – preventing sensitive U.S. citizen and business confidential information related to their intellectual property from being stored and processed in cloud computing systems related to adversary countries, such as Alibaba, Baidu, China Mobile, China Telecom, and Tencent; v) Clean Cable – ensuring that submarine cable networks connecting the United States to other countries are not subject to the collection of intelligence signals by the Chinese government, in relation to the global Internet, and this guarantee should be extended to other countries impacted by submarine cable networks. As noted, the targets of the U.S. foreign policy strategy toward China are: telecommunications network infrastructure, application stores, applications themselves, cloud computing infrastructure, and submarine cable networks.

The U.S. government is studying measures to order Internet service providers to block TikTok and WeChat applications. So, for example, Google may be forced to prevent the installation of Chinese applications on its Android software.  Also, Amazon may be required to remove Chinese applications from its store. Another possible measure is the obligation to divest TikTok and WeChat operations in the United States, thus US citizens and companies could be forced to divest themselves of investment interests in Chinese companies.

The measures are adopted in the context of the dispute between the United States and China for global leadership. The United States sees China as a threat to its global leadership, especially in the face of 5G technology, led by Chinese company Huawei.

[1] Executive Order on addressing the threat posed by WeChat, August 6, 2020.

[2] Executive order on addressing the threat posed by TikTok, August, 6, 2020.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Themes of communication law in the jurisprudence of the Brazilian Supreme Court

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2017

Sold by: Amazon Serviços de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

The Brazil Constitution celebrates the 30 (Thirtieth) anniversary in 2018.
The book Communication Law in the Case Law of the Brazilian Supreme Court, by the author Ericson M. Scorsim (PhD in Law, by Universidade de São Paulo), lawyer and consultant in Public Law, aims at honoring this historic and symbolic event in Brazil.
The book provides a comprehensive overview of Brazilian decisions on cases about the Regulatory Framework of the Internet, Telecommunications (Telecommunications Act), Broadcasting, Pay-TV (Pay-TV Act) and the Press, in the last three decades, from 1988 (when the Constitution of Brazil was approved) until 2018.
During this period of time, the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court established the basis of Communication Law.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Direito da Comunicação

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Edition 2, year 2016

Vendido por: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

O Direito da Comunicação tem como foco a legislação aplicável aos serviços de internet, telecomunicações, televisão por radiodifusão, TV por assinatura e publicidade.
No livro, o autor Ericson M. Scorsim analisa questões regulatórias, legais, contratuais e da jurisprudência brasileira.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Temas de Derecho de las Comunicaciones en la jurisprudencia del Supremo Tribunal Federal

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2018

Spanish

Sold by: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

El libro destaca la jurisprudencia del Supremo Tribunal Federal de Brasil sobre los sectores de internet, telecomunicaciones, radiodifusión y Tv por suscripción, en el período que va de 1998 a 2008.
La obra está destinada a América Latina, México, España y la comunidad hispana residente en los Estados Unidos. Es de interés de los abogados, profesores de derecho, estudiantes, periodistas, autoridades reguladoras, inversores y emprendedores, ejecutivos de los sectores de internet, telecomunicaciones, radiodifusión y la tv por suscripción.
Este libro, segundo volumen de una colección de tras libros sobre Derecho de la Comunicación, está dedicado a los Temas de Derecho de la Comunicación em la jurisprudencia del Supremo Tribunal Federal.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Communication Law in Brazil

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2017

English

Sold by: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

Communications Law is the field dedicated to the laws and regulations that apply to telecommunications, Internet, and television services . This field of law examines the legislation applicable to different telecommunication services (landlines and personal mobile lines), Internet access and Internet applications, broadcast radio and TV, and Pay TV.
The inspiration to write about Communications Law came from realizing the value of knowledge of this new area of law, which can make a major contribution to the practice of legal professionals and those from other areas.
The chapters of the book Communications Law present a new vision for organizing and aligning fundamental themes in laws related to social communication, the internet, telecommunications, and broadcast and pay television.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Droit de la Communication au Brésil

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2016

French

Sold by: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

Le Droit des Communications Au Brèsil est centré sur la législation applicable à internet, aux télécommunications, à la télévision par radiodiffusion, à la télévision payante et à la publicité.

Dans ce livre, Mr. Ericson M. Scorsim analyse les questions réglementaires, légales, contractuelles ainsi que la jurisprudence brésilienne dans ce domaine.

Les sujets abordés ont une répercussion sur la pratique des professionnels de droit et des domaines économiques réglementés.

Categories
Books

Ebook Kindle Derecho de la Comunicacion en Brasil

Author: Ericson M. Scorsim

Year: 2016

Spanish

Sold by: Amazon Servicos de Varejo do Brasil Ltda

El Derecho de las Comunicaciones se focaliza en la legislación aplicable a los servicios de internet, telecomunicaciones, televisión por radiodifusión, TV por suscripción y publicidad.
En el libro, el autor Ericson M. Scorsim analiza las cuestiones regulatorias, legales, contractuales y de la jurisprudencia brasilera.

Categories
Articles

The Geostrategic Option for Brazil to Strengthen Data Infrastructure: A Review of the European Cloud Computing Project GAIA-X

Ericson Scorsim. Lawyer and Consultant in Communication Law. PhD in Law from the University of São Paulo (USP). Author of the book collection on Communication Law, with a focus on Technologies, Media, and Telecommunications.

The European Union, under the leadership of France and Germany, is carrying out the project called GAIA-X for data infrastructure. The aim is to strengthen the European Union’s sovereignty over data to encourage the creation of a digital ecosystem.  According to the program’s official documents: “data sovereignty in the sense of complete control over stored and processed data and also the independent decision on who is permitted to have access to it”.[1] And also on data sovereignty: “sovereign data services which ensure the identity of source and receiver of data and which ensure the access and usage rights towards the data”.[2] In the text, one of the stated objectives is: “protection against non-European extra-territorial regulatory: protection again t abuse of national regulations that allow to access data stored in cloud infrastructures or services is an essential part of the European federated data infrastructure“.[3] The data infrastructure is a federative infrastructure that consists of components and services that make it possible to access, store, exchange, and use data according to pre-defined rules.

The digital ecosystem is the network of developers, providers and users of digital products and services. In short, the aim of the GAIA-X project is to provide incentives to European cloud computing companies, ensuring the competitiveness of European Union countries. It is categorically stated that the project is a geostrategic response by the European Union to the passing of the Cloud Act by the United States. It is also a reaction to the competitiveness of the U.S. companies IBM, Microsoft, Google, and Amazon, which are leaders in the infrastructure as service market.   There is only one global Chinese competitor in this segment: Alibaba.

The project is set in the context of the unique data market and the strengthening of the European digital economy. For the European Union, there is the public policy of defending the data of European industry. Starting in 2021, the project is expected to be completed with the installation of cloud computing infrastructures. One of the main points of the project is to ensure interoperability between systems to enable migration to European cloud computing companies. Another goal is to ensure control over data on European territory. This European Union geostrategy for strengthening data infrastructure capacity can serve as an inspiration for Brazil. In this respect, a national policy of incentives for data infrastructure capacity is needed, aligned with an industrial policy and digital trade policy, and including national defense policy. These public policies are essential for the country’s adaptation in the 5G technology and  Internet of Things scenario, allowing for the best economic use.  After all, the country that controls the 5G digital infrastructure controls its digital economy. In Brazil, the main telecommunication companies present here have European headquarters (Tim and Telefonica, except for Mexico’s América Móvel, and Oi and Algar Telecom).

These telecommunications companies have the fundamental role of deploying connectivity in Brazilian territory. Thus, they have the ultimate responsibility for defining how best to provide 5G technology. Also, the main suppliers of 5G technology are European: Ericcson (Sweden) and Nokia (Finland). In Asia, there’s South Korea with Samsung. Thus, Brazil has other interesting geostrategic options regarding 5G technology that go beyond those offered by the United States and China. The best thing for Brazil is to maintain neutrality in this conflict for global leadership between the United States and China. But the country can take advantage of the opportunities in redefining the global 5G technology supply chain, with incentives to attract foreign investments in this production chain here in Brazil, attracting investments in microchip factories and installation of data centers. It is essential for Brazil, like the European Union, to reflect on the risks of abuse in the application of U.S. legislation (Cloud Act), which allows access to data located in other countries. It is key for Brazil to affirm its sovereignty in cyberspace, strengthening its capacity for cyber defense against possible risks of abuses in the application of foreign legislation in an extraterritorial manner. 

In the coming decades, 5G, IoT, artificial intelligence, and big data will be the driving forces of the digital economy, which is why it is essential for the country to prepare itself for this global scenario.

[1] Project GAIA-X. A Federated Data Infrastructure as the Cradle of a Vibrant European Ecosystem. Federated Data Infrastructure. Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy and Federal Ministry of Education and Research.

[2]Work cited.

[3] Project GAIA-X. A Federated Data Infrastructure as the Cradle of a Vibrant European Ecosystem. Federated Data Infrastructure. Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy and Federal Ministry of Education and Research.